Urban Reviews appealed to me because, when I first looked at it, I noticed several reviews that mentioned writing and editing qualities. I can guess why quality is not often addressed in reviews, but I regret the lack, especially with urban fiction, which is so often self-published or published by houses that seem to have minuscule editing budgets.
For personal reading, you might find and follow a reviewer whose taste aligns with your own; for advisory interactions, however, quality may or may not be a factor. Still, I prefer reviews that address writing and editing quality as well as provide a simple description of plot. Smart Bitches Trashy Books is my go-to for romance reviews because they give letter grades and do not hesitate to call out inconsistencies, historical inaccuracies, etc.
No comments:
Post a Comment